For the presentation on the Cambodian Donut Shop, I
thought it was pretty interesting because I’ve never actually heard or even
considered this trend in donut shops throughout the country. It seems that the Jason had already
done some pretty basic research on this topic already since he explained about
how it was an internship that he worked on. The information that he presented was pretty straight to the
point and focused. I really
enjoyed the article that he gave to the class because it gave us background
knowledge of how the whole Cambodian donut business started and the demise of
the initial business owner.
Although the topic was covered really
well, I feel like it is a little too broad to write a research paper on. If Jason plans to write his research
paper on this, the information he has can still be used, but he can also add on
more about the conflicts and struggles that these family owned business
encounter in their community. The
clip that he showed in class did a great job at portraying the discrimination
and economic struggles that these owners go through. So if he can implement these things into his essay, I think
it will make his essay really strong.
For
the presentation on Inter-ethnic conflicts in the South, I thought that their
class discussions very helpful in getting the class more interactive. Because the topic of research is
something that many of the students in class can relate, I thought that the
discussion really helped us reflect on how our school system compare to the
participants’. In terms of the
presentation, the group’s analysis and critique of the article was really on
point. The background information
given was really brief and concise which offered more time for other
information and discussion. For
one of the concept that was presented, the Black-and-White view, I thought that
there could have been a little more information or examples given because some
of the students in the group discussion seemed a little confused when we had to
answer a question that pertained to it.
Aside from that, the solutions that were
presented in the article and articulated by the presenters were very
clear. It would be great if the
students suggest more solutions that can also be use to improve the problems in
the school AND the community. For
example, the film that we watched, “Eating Welfare,” has a strong message about
Southeast Asian American youth empowerment and voice. Based on the collaboration of many youth, a movement started
which gave these youth hope to change and speak out. If a suggested collaboration of YOUTH programs were
available, it would create some sort of solidarity between marginalized groups
and dominant groups.
Another suggestion that I think would be helpful for their research is
the improvements that they can make from the article’s research. As part of SAFE, these presenters can
conduct a similar research to see if this outdated research still applies to
the youth in the Sacramento area. If
this was conducted at the outreach schools, I think it would have been really interesting to see if
these students still feel the same way despite the availability of ESL classes
and ethnic-related organizations. -Brenda Vue
Great insights. Very good and helpful feedback. -Prof. Valverde
ReplyDelete